Hey, Jerry Reese, are you there? Wake up! Come on, please wake up,
free agency has begun. “What’s that?” you ask? Oh jeez, get ready for
a long season.
The New York Giants went 10-6 last season but failed to make the
playoffs for the second consecutive season, putting head coach Tom
Coughlin on the hot seat for the time being. In reality, the only
member of the Giants’ front office that should be on the hot seat is
GM Jerry Reese, who has been so inactive during the last month that
all of his staff and family members have been calling him non-stop
wondering if he is still alive.
The Giants’ big offseason move thus far has been resigning running
back Ahmad Bradshaw. The Giants rewarded the oft-injured Bradshaw by
assuring him that they would be placing $18 million in his slippery
hands over the next four years – Bradshaw fumbled 7 times last year,
good for second in the NFL behind Browns’ halfback Peyton Hillis.
Don’t get me wrong, Bradshaw is an extremely effective player when he
is healthy. In fact, Bradshaw rushed for 1,235 yards on 276 attempts
last year, an average of 4.5 yards per carry. His yards total placed
him 9th in the NFL, not bad for someone who only started 11 games and
shared the load with Brandon Jacobs. Bradshaw has been held back due
to several ankle and foot problems, eventually leading to surgical
procedures. Resigning him was a good move and something that had to be
done, but when you mention that as your biggest move in the entire
offseason, something is wrong.
The Giants also resigned Mathias Kiwanuka to a two year deal worth
$8.6 million. Boy, it sure must feel great to miss 13 games, have no
definite position and still have the luxury of adding that type of
money to your bank account. Kiwanuka was a defensive end, then a
linebacker, then a defensive end, then a defensive tackle, then an end
again, and then he got injured and missed 13 games of the 2010 season
– now he is getting paid all that money to play where exactly? The
Giants seem to be pretty deep at the defensive end position and
extremely thin at linebacker, so perhaps a position change back to
linebacker is in the works for Kiwanuka. He is also a solid player
when he is healthy. Kiwanuka’s best season was 2008 when he had 8
sacks and 51 tackles, while starting in all 16 games. He recorded 4
sacks in just 3 games last season before getting injured.
The Giants let tight end Kevin Boss sign with the Oakland Raiders,
leaving the team with no solid option at the position. Travis Beckum
can certainly catch the ball but he is too small and cannot block,
while Bear Pascoe uses his big body to block effectively without
having the luxury of having the ability to catch a pass. The two
replacement options are the exact opposite of one another and a lot of
two tight end sets appear evident for the Giants this upcoming season,
unless they find a tight end out there who can both block and catch.
Say what you want about Kevin Boss, but he was a tough player who took
a beating and still produced. Boss was one of Eli Manning’s favorite
targets in past years, catching 110 passes for 16 touchdowns in the
three seasons since becoming a starter. Boss missed three games in
those three years.
The wide receiver position just got a lot thinner today with the news
that Giants’ receiver Steve Smith signed a one year deal with the
Philadelphia Eagles. You have to be kidding me – resigning Smith
appeared to be a no-brainer. Although he is still recovering from
micro fracture knee surgery and will not be ready for the start of the
2011 season, the Eagles have already won just by prying Smith away
from New York. Steve Smith became a starter in the 2009 season and
immediately exploded into a star, earning his spot on the Pro Bowl
roster. Smith caught 107 balls for 1,220 yards and 7 TD’s during that
season. Smith was 2nd in the NFL in receptions and 8th in the NFL in
receiving yards that season. Smith has 20 career receptions for 201
yards in four games against the Philadelphia Eagles and was always the
go-to guy for the Giants on offense. It seemed like every 3rd down,
Manning would pass it to Smith for the first down. During the 2009
season, statistics show that Eli Manning targeted Steve Smith 157
times, 29.4% of the time he threw the ball.
Osi Umenyiora is starting to cry again, and this time it is getting
very ugly. Last preseason, Umenyiora started his antics and left
practice early in an effort to plead his case to the Giants’ front
office. He felt like he was cheated by Jerry Reese, saying that Reese
promised him a contract extension which Umenyiora has yet to receive.
He called the general manager a liar but eventually quieted down and
played football, realizing that the Giants had leverage due to the
fact that Osi missed the entire 2008 season because of injury.
Umenyiora started all 16 games for the Giants in 2010 and recorded
11.5 sacks, tying fellow defensive end Justin Tuck for the team lead.
Umenyiora also forced 10 fumbles, most in the NFL by a ton, with James
Hall coming in second with 6. The tension between the two sides has
gotten worse over the last week, with the Giants granting Umenyiora
the right to seek his own trade and then eventually rescinding the
offer. Umenyiora is currently a camp holdout and is apparently
visiting a doctor in his hometown to check out his “knee discomfort”.
Most people feel as if this is just a ploy for Umenyiora to get out of
New York.
With two less options to throw to, Eli Manning might have a hard time
driving down the field and putting the ball in the end zone this
season. It might be even harder for him given the fact that the Giants
are going to start Will Beatty and David Baas on the offensive line,
losing a few key members including center Shaun O’Hara. The defense is
already hampered, having lost safety Michael Johnson to the Seattle
Seahawks and electing to not resign safety Deon Grant. The Giants’
number one draft pick, corner back Prince Amukamara, is expected to
miss two months after breaking his foot a few days ago. Amukamara will
undergo a surgical procedure that involves inserting screws into the
foot, which does not sound good at all. The Giants still have no
linebackers, for the third straight season. The one definite
linebacker is Michael Boley, who is horrendous. Jonathan Goff is
expected to start at middle linebacker for the second straight season
after recording 78 total tackles in 2010. The other linebacker will
either be Mathias Kiwanuka or Clint Sintim.
To put it simply, the Giants have not made any improvements to a team
that missed the playoffs a season ago, and you can definitely make the
case that they have gotten worse given all of their departures. How
can the Giants save their uneventful offseason? The obvious choice
would be to go out and sign a good receiver, since Ramses Barden is
currently third on the depth chart. Jerricho Cotchery showed that he
can both play in the NFL and have success playing in New York when he
received over 800 yards in every season from 2006-2009 as a member of
the Jets.
We will see how the season pans out, but it is hard to imagine the
Giants making the playoffs this season. They have only gotten worse
this offseason and the Philadelphia Eagles have signed everyone and
immediately become the Super Bowl favorites. The Dallas Cowboys will
have quarter back Tony Romo healthy and it is hard to imagine them
being as bad as last season, when they went 6-10. It will be very
difficult for the Giants to be successful this season, or at least it
appears so. If Osi Umenyiora plays and is as effective as last season
then maybe the Giants’ strong defensive line can cover up for a weak
line backing unit. If the Giants sign a good free agent wide receiver
and/or tight end then that will help a depleted passing attack and
have the offense firing on all cylinders again. Those are a lot of
“ifs”, however.
Written by Daniel Ferrara (Twitter @Ferrara34)